joyr1d38 (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

Definitely not live. The whole record "Catch a Fire" is overdubbed in London. The original recordings you can buy on CD, they are much rougher and don't have that twangy keyboard. Notice Peter Tosh is faking the keyboard piece on his guitar for the video, but it is actually a keyboard. Actually a guy from Texas wrote the keyboard piece for this song. There is an interview where he talks about first hitting those notes and Bob comes running in forcing a joint down his throat.

joyr1d38 (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

The one with the fez on.

henryfan88 (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

two of the best singers/bands played at whistle test bob marley and the ramones and many more.

djimaginarys (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

I agree with you Quilbo

kriswhat (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

PETER TOSH !

buck1969 (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

Bunny is the one if your looking at Bob on his right

Lemev (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

Does anybody know which one is Bunny Wailer? Thanx!

deweypug (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

Just to lay this one to rest - This is the studio recording being played. It is NOT live. IF you would like to find out for yourselves, spin the disc and start this vid. It is dead on.

popolochita (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

This was the "Whistle Test" - it was live. It was a late night hard core show on BBC2 as opposed to "Top of the Pops" on BBC1 which was not live.

mazaradiaz (January 1, 1970 at 7:29 am)

agree with you